Comparing Kaplan and Manhattan Prep GMAT for high scorers. Analysis of teaching methods, practice materials, and value for 700+ scorers.
Kaplan GMAT vs Manhattan Prep: Which Course for 700+?
For GMAT 700+ scorers, Kaplan and Manhattan Prep are the industry leaders. Both cost around $1,599-1,799 and offer comprehensive prep with live instruction. Kaplan emphasizes systematic strategies and volume, while Manhattan Prep focuses on conceptual understanding and smaller classes. Both can get you to 700+, but they serve different learning styles.
Quick Comparison
Feature | Kaplan GMAT | Manhattan Prep GMAT Price | $1,599 | $1,799 Live Class Hours | 35 hours | 27 hours Practice Tests | 6 official + Kaplan tests | 6 official + Manhattan tests Class Size | 20-25 students | 12-15 students Best For | Systematic learners | Conceptual learners
Teaching Philosophy: Different Approaches
Kaplan GMAT uses systematic strategies built around the Kaplan Method. You learn specific approaches for Quant, Verbal, Integrated Reasoning, and Data Insights. The content is structured with progressive drills. Kaplan assumes you need repetition and systematic practice to master GMAT patterns.
Manhattan Prep GMAT emphasizes conceptual understanding. Their instructors teach you to think like the GMAT, not just memorize strategies. Classes are more Socratic with discussion and problem-solving. Manhattan Prep assumes you learn best by understanding underlying concepts.
Winner: Kaplan for systematic learners. Manhattan Prep for conceptual learners.
Live Instruction: Quantity vs Quality
Kaplan provides 35 hours of live instruction, which is 8 hours more than Manhattan Prep. Classes are taught by 90th percentile scorers. The live sessions focus on teaching the Kaplan Method and working through practice problems.
Manhattan Prep offers 27 hours of live instruction with smaller class sizes (12-15 vs 20-25). Their instructors scored in the 99th percentile. The smaller classes allow more personalized attention and discussion.
Winner: Kaplan for total hours. Manhattan Prep for class size and instructor quality.
Practice Materials: Similar Quality
Both courses include 6 official GMAT practice tests plus proprietary tests. Kaplan provides more total practice questions, while Manhattan Prep emphasizes quality explanations.
Winner: Tie. Both provide excellent practice materials.
Price and Value
Kaplan costs $1,599. Manhattan Prep costs $1,799. The $200 difference is minimal.
Kaplan gives you more hours (35 vs 27). Manhattan Prep gives you smaller classes and 99th percentile instructors.
Winner: Depends on whether you value quantity (Kaplan) or quality (Manhattan Prep).
Who Should Choose Kaplan GMAT?
You want systematic strategies and structure. You prefer more hours of instruction (35 vs 27). You are comfortable in larger classes (20-25 students). You learn best through repetition and drills. You want to save $200.
Who Should Choose Manhattan Prep GMAT?
You prefer conceptual understanding over memorization. You want smaller classes (12-15 students). You value 99th percentile instructors. You learn best through discussion and problem-solving. You can afford the extra $200.
The Bottom Line
Both Kaplan and Manhattan Prep are excellent GMAT courses worth the investment. The choice comes down to learning style: systematic strategies and volume (Kaplan), or conceptual understanding and personalized attention (Manhattan Prep). Both can get you to 700+ if you put in the work.
For a complete breakdown of the Data Insights section, see our GMAT Data Insights Complete Guide.
FAQ
Q: Is Kaplan Gmat or Manhattan Prep better for GMAT prep? A: Both have strengths. Check our detailed comparison above for a side-by-side analysis of pricing, content quality, instructor credentials, and student outcomes to determine which is the better fit for your needs.
Q: Which is more affordable, Kaplan Gmat or Manhattan Prep? A: Pricing varies by plan tier. See the pricing comparison table in our review above for current prices. Remember that the cheapest option is not always the best value when you factor in score guarantees and access periods.
Q: Can I switch from Kaplan Gmat to Manhattan Prep mid-study? A: Most prep courses do not offer transfer credits. If you are considering switching, check the refund policy of your current course first. Some courses offer 7-14 day money-back guarantees.